Johnston & Murphy Gibbons Cap Toe Oxford

I bought these shoes in August of last year. They fit perfectly and are very comfortable, but unfortunately the quality is terrible. About six months after I started wearing them, the sole started to come apart. That’s when I realized it isn’t actually stitched—the thread that is supposed to join the sole is completely fake, and instead the glue used is of disastrous quality. I’ve tried to glue them back in several ways, but the result has not been satisfactory. During the process the bonding ends up uneven and stained with adhesive. The sad thing is that they keep coming apart to the point of becoming unusable. I live out of the USA so returning them wasn’t an easy option. I am very disappointed with this product and would not recommend the dress shoe line to anyone.

I only ever wear Johnston and Murphy for my dress shoes. My old ones needed replacing after wearing them everyday for 2 years due to scuff marks that weren’t savable. These shoes had a nicer looking insole and appeared classy like the rest of the J&Ms I’ve had, but the outside material seems cheaper and firmer than needed. They have not gotten much better after wearing them for 3 weeks. Almost too stiff to enjoy.

Got these for an upcoming wedding, great fit, great value! No break in time needed, service out of this world!

One of the best dress shoes I have ever had. It comfortable and stylish concurrents.

Great shoes. I have always been a fan of Johnston and murphy. These didn't disappoint.

Great style and color and more comfortable than I expected

Good fit, great support for me to wear on long 16 hour days

They look great in person. I don’t have a problem putting them on because I put the laces in. So comfort it great.