Rated 4 out of 5
Nice Penny Loafer
I just got these so I haven’t worn them a lot. They look great! After I wear them a while the shoes rub on the top of my feet. I think I just have to break them in more.
By Acamp
Never sacrifice comfort for style again! The Eastland Classic II loafer is the perfect dress or casual style that will perfectly compliment your work wear wardrobe.
Rated 4 out of 5
I just got these so I haven’t worn them a lot. They look great! After I wear them a while the shoes rub on the top of my feet. I think I just have to break them in more.
By Acamp
Rated 1 out of 5
The material feels really cheap and fake. I got an 8.5 thinking it would be enough room to wear with socks but they were way too big. I'll be returning
By Sadlydidntwork
Rated 4 out of 5
I brought two pairs - a navy that I received right away, and a light brown that I received a few days later in uncovered box and showing inside marks of sweaty toes that I returned…
By Andeoli
Rated 4 out of 5
Not sure if these shoes were a return or not. Shoes came in a box with lid cut off. Shoes were not wrapped in tissue paper or usual shoe packaging. They do fit true to size and really like the memory foam. The burgundy color was really dark almost thought they were brown not a true burgundy. I have a retro pair and the difference in color was very noticeable. Really disappointed to find they were made in China not a fan of paying $100 for shoes made in China.
By Smiley
Rated 5 out of 5
Bought this shoe in two different colors. They are incredibly comfortable! They were even better after some leather conditioner was applied.
By Lea A
Rated 5 out of 5
This is one of the most comfortable loafers that I have ever owned. It fits well and cushions my foot better than any other I have owned.
By JHfoot
Rated 5 out of 5
Great classic loafer! Very comfortable. I did order 1/2 size larger so I could wear with socks.
By bcindi
Rated 1 out of 5
Received used return shoes at full price DSW don’t shop warehouse
By Soup
Rated 5 out of 5
I just bought these. They are comfortable right out of the box! The shoes are well made. I highly recommend them!
By Amethyst 125
Rated 2 out of 5
DSW sent wrong color. I ordered burgundy and they sent walnut. I did not like that color and the shoes looked cheap. I have sent back for full refund.
By Pamh
Rated 4 out of 5
Purchased black and burgandy. Received the wrong color I think. As someone else mentioned, they too received Walnut as stated on the box. Does Burgundy even exist? I wear size 8 in Brooks sneakers but 7.5m fit best in this loafer. They fit just right. Good price
By Dandelion
Rated 4 out of 5
This is a classic, well- made loafer. The leather is quite stiff, though, so it may take a while to ’break in’. They have good padding on the insole, but they seem to run narrow. Even the wide was tough to get on.
By Elaine
Rated 5 out of 5
The loafers are great, even though I received the wrong color. I ordered burgundy but received walnut. I'm still keeping them because the color is very close. It still would have been nice to receive my correct order. This isn't the first time this has happened.
By DeeKC
Rated 5 out of 5
I’ve owned these shoes in the color “tan” for over six years now, and I wear them to work regularly. They are extremely comfortable and still look great! Thank you Eastland — as long as you make these shoes, you’ve got yourselves a loyal customer for life.
By Maddie
Rated 5 out of 5
I wear shoes to a volunteer shift of 4 hours. These shoes look good and comfy all at the same time.
By Shoe Lover
Rated 3 out of 5
I really wanted these to fit. They are very cute, great with skirts or jeans. But they do run narrow. Normally I always wear medium width shoes, but I could barely get these on in medium. Wide was a bit better; they fit the front of my feet, but the heels were too loose and kept flopping. Had to return. Otherwise, they seem to be good quality, and the length fit true to size.
By CarrieLynn92
Rated 1 out of 5
What is wrong with your shipping department. This is the second pair of shoes I ordered with a damaged box...no lid and no packing material. Another return item or just incompetent packing? Fortunately the shoes are undamaged and will keep. Not happy to be spending good money for this crap. Shoes are great but better not have this happen again!
By MJCKS
Rated 5 out of 5
LOVE THEM! I am so pleased to find this quality loafer in a wide size! I haven't had a pair since I was a kid and am very excited. They are as comfortable as slippers, and I like the non skid sole. I was worried they wouldnt be large/wide enough so I ordered up, a size 9 W, which was too big. Exchanged them for my usual size 8.5 W and they fit perfectly.
By AK77
Rated 4 out of 5
I wanted to keep these shoes so badly. I have been searching for the perfect wide, leather, burgundy shoes for years and I thought I found them. The quality and comfort were perfect but the wide was not wide enough for my foot. Sometimes I do not need to order wide and many of ,my shoes are normal width so I would say that the wide runs narrow in my opinion. I did also just buy a wide leather boot from DSW that I did keep but would also say I would have liked it to be wider so maybe I am wrong.
By Heather
Rated 2 out of 5
I've had previous Eastland penny loafers over a few decades, they were my daily shoes, wore them till they wore out. This time around, I ordered my normal shoe size of 10M, had to return as they were too big, especially at the sides. Reordered size 9.5M, but unfortunately will be returning these as well. Too tight on both little toe sides and make my toes "crack" when walking. Not willing to spend time stretching or breaking the shoes in and then having them still not feel right. Also, compared to my previous Eastland tan loafers, this TAN color (for being new shoes) is much darker, more like medium-dark brown which I don't want. The style of these shoes is still great, the leather is fine as well as the non-slip soles, the heel and side areas fit fine. Just wish there was more room in the toe area.
By jocats9